Rani Mukerji Faces Backlash for Claiming Indian Films are the Best in the World: Critics Counter with Mention of ’12th Fail’ Against Iranian Cinema

Rani Mukerji Expresses Praise for ’12th Fail’ Following Controversy Over Iranian Cinema Remark, Twitter Reacts to the Developments

Twitter Roasts Rani Mukerji’s Assertion of ‘Indian Cinema Being the Best in the World’ Amid Positive Response to Vikrant Massey’s ’12th Fail’

Rani Mukerji recently claimed that India produces the best films globally during a roundtable discussion. She cited Vikrant Massey’s film “12th Fail,” based on the life of IPS officer Manoj Kumar Sharma, as an example. This assertion came in response to filmmaker Prithvi Konanur’s statement that Iranian cinema surpasses Indian films in terms of ideas. Rani’s comment faced criticism on social media, with some users expressing disagreement and labeling her take as “garbage.”

In the conversation, filmmaker Prithvi Konanur expressed his opinion about Iranian cinema, stating that he encourages people to watch Iranian films. He highlighted that there is a notable difference between Indian and Iranian films. According to Konanur, Iranian cinema is advanced in terms of ideas, even though there might be a technological difference. He suggested that viewers watch Iranian films to appreciate the depth of ideas present in their cinema.

Rani Mukerji responded to Prithvi Konanur’s statement by expressing offense and strongly asserting her belief that Indian cinema is the best in the world. She disagreed with the idea of learning from other cinemas and emphasized the diversity and richness of Indian films. Rani pointed to the film “12th Fail” as an example of brilliant storytelling that reflects the depth and authenticity of Indian cinema. She argued that Indian cinema offers the truest and most grounded stories, and she did not want to compare it with any other cinema in the world.

The tweet highlights a critical perspective, expressing disagreement with Rani Mukerji’s statement. The user criticizes the portrayal of poverty in the film “12th Fail,” suggesting that it relied on brownface makeup for the protagonist to appear poor. Additionally, the user criticizes Karan Johar’s liking for the film “Animal,” implying a lack of substance in Bollywood.

These tweets express skepticism and disagreement with Rani Mukerji’s statement. The first tweet suggests that Rani Mukerji’s points lack coherence, potentially due to a limited exposure to films from other countries. The second tweet critiques the idea of claiming India as the best without acknowledgment from others, portraying it as pompous.

These tweets express a sense of irony and amusement in response to Rani Mukerji countering the argued brilliance of Iranian cinema with the film “12th Fail.” The mention of Satyajit Ray adds another layer of irony, suggesting a contrast between the acclaimed filmmaker’s perspective and the type of cinema represented by “12th Fail.” Overall, these tweets highlight the perceived mismatch between the examples given and the assertion about the quality of Indian cinema.

This tweet questions Rani Mukerji’s assertion that Indian cinema is the best in the world by pointing out the perceived struggle of Indian films to find recognition in international circuits. The user suggests that despite making various kinds of films, the overall quality may not align with the claim of being the best.

“12th Fail,” highlighting Vikrant Massey’s portrayal of Manoj Kumar Sharma and the challenges faced on his path to becoming an IPS officer. Additionally, it mentions Medha Shankar’s role as Shraddha Joshi, Manoj’s wife, who is an IRS officer. The film’s availability on Disney+ Hotstar, its recognition with an independent nomination for Oscars 2024, and its theatrical release in October 2023 are also highlighted.